Gargoyles: Eye of the Beholder – Episode Review

Follow VLN Research on

Happy Valentine’s Day, and an early Happy Halloween! Welcome to one of my all-time favorite episodes, Eye of the Beholder. In this episode, David Xanatos proposes to Fox, who agrees. They seal the deal with the Eye of Odin. It’s no coincidence that right after, werefox sightings appear around the city. Elisa meets the creature face to hairy face. But it’s up to Xanatos and Owen to save Fox before the eye destroys her. She’s not too hot on the idea, though. Or rather, Were!Fox isn’t.

Miss last week’s ep? It’s nowhere near as good as today’s Red Fox ep, but it was The Silver Falcon.

Spoilers are in the 20/20 moments. Info from Ask Greg is in the According to Greg bits.

Season 2, Episode 7: Eye of the Beholder

Reason(s) for existence: To explore the theme of love. The advance the David/Fox relationship. To introduce the Eye of Odin. To show that the clan and Xanatos can work together. To show that Goliath is wiser than he seems.

Main antagonist(s): Fox, David Xanatos (by complete accident this time)

Time(s):  October 1st-31st, 1995

Location(s): New York City, New York

Previously: We’re reminded that Xanatos has the Eye of Odin in his private collection again during The Edge. We’re also reminded that he and Fox are an item as they kiss in the limo in Leader of the Pack‘s Xanatos Tag. Ooh, this all bodes wonderfully well! A David and Fox ep? Sign me up.

Forget the Ring

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - xanatos looking at fox over coffe tea

Gotta love this self-satisfied prick. <3

We open on the great hall of the castle. I love when we open on the Eyrie Building! We jump right into the action. David and Fox are having a tux and gown dinner for two. Owen is playing butler tonight. Xanatos is smirk-smiling over his coffee/tea/whatever at Fox. “Marry me,” he announces.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - xanatos proposes

Total confidence: you’re doing it right.

It’s telling that Fox is surprised, but only just. “Are you serious?”

David’s response is classic: “It makes perfect sense to get married. We’re genetically compatible, highly intelligent, and share the same goals.”

Doncha just love how he compliments himself at the same time he compliments Fox? He’s 100% accurate, though. Mm, what about that “genetically compatible” line? David Xanatos wants to be a dad? I…well, he does enjoy shaping people’s lives. He also enjoys having people around him who are loyal and who look up to him. Y’know, the kind of people everybody wants around them. Still, the great trickster and antagonist having a kid is just…really intriguing. Leave it to the ground-breaking writers at Gargoyles to rewrite the rules of antagonists in American animated series. Who else but them would give the antag a love interest with whom he has a completely healthy relationship? Who else but them would give said antagonists a kid?

According to Greg: I say this every time there’s a Fox/David ep, but Greg is still amazed he got the relationship past the BIG BOSSES and S&P at Disney. They didn’t realize that a BF/GF relationship could turn into engagement, which would lead to marriage, which would lead to a kid. Our gain!

Fox asks, “What about…love?”

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - fox asks david about love

She sounds like she doesn’t think it’s anything to worry about, but everybody else seems to, so just so we’re on the same page, Ok, David?

“I think we love each other, as much as two people such as ourselves are capable of that emotion.”

According to Greg: Xanatos should by this time know he loves Fox. I’ll point out his line in Leader, “True love is so much harder to come by.” Maybe he said the truth in the heat of the moment, and now he’s reconsidered to save his view of himself. Greg says David considers himself too amoral to be capable of love. I admit, love from a person with Fox and David’s personality type is far different from the average person’s. I totally get it, though. It’s a devotion, a fierce loyalty, a desire to protect and help the object of their affection.

Owen opens a box containing the Eye of Odin. It’s to “seal the deal.”

“Proposal accepted,” Fox decides.

I’ve heard some people say this is a lame proposal plan, one not worthy of Xanatos. ORLY? Do tell how a private, elegant, direct proposal with its reason based on logic and common interest is not Xanatosian? Xanatos isn’t going to mince words. He has intense respect for Fox; his actions stem from this attitude. In this proposal scene, he is 100% the charming, ambitious man Fox fell in love with.

20/20 moment / According to Greg: Nine months after this night, Alexander Fox Xanatos is born. Take that, S&P.

And heck, who wouldn’t accept a marriage offer from Xanatos, the richest man on earth? He’s brilliant and easy on the eyes too. Ok, moving in…

Store Run

At Mr. Jaffe’s General Store, things are about to get real. Jaffe flees as store goods fly out the windows.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - general store destroyed

Poor guy, first armed robberies, and now…what?

Elisa is conveniently nearby. She investigates without waiting for backup. What else is new? The store looks like a horde of hungry college students attacked it. Ever the wise one, Elisa follows the sound of chewing and growling. She finds a werewolf.  Oh, and the werewolf is wearing the Eye of Odin. Lovely.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - werefox eating

Huh. It is the garg-verse, after all.

Elisa learns not to interrupt a werebeast’s binge: the creature knocks the pistol out of Elisa’s hands and pins her against a pile of flour bags. Elisa whacks the beast over the head with said flour.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - werefox grabs elisa

Nobody light a match. That stuff’ll blow like gas fumes.

Backup arrives, but the werewolf is gone.

I gotta say, that’s a cool werebeast. It’s cut and ripped, has great hair, and is apparently intelligent. None of this stupid Harry Potter gangly geek werewolf stuff.

Officer Morgan tells Elisa he can’t get through a shift this month without cleaning up after the beast. That’s a lot of food.

Xanatos and Owen are watching Travis Marshal’s news report on the incident (first sighting was October 4th – why the delay?). They’re not at all surprised, as this has been a common news story. Now, isn’t this beast thing setting the city in a panic? No, I guess not. After all, the city didn’t even blink when robot gargoyles attacked multiple times.

Fox pads in, barefoot and in a trench coat.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - fox in xanatos's office

Um…is this normal? Cuz the boys act like it’s totally normal to have her wander through the office in this state. What kind of life do you people lead? Never mind; I’m about to find out, aren’t I. Sweet.

Xanatos tactfully asks where she’s been “hiding herself” and if she has the Eye on. She says she’s been on a walk. Where in that outfit? Central Park to flash people? And all night? Look, when a man gets you out of prison early and says he missed you, he’s doesn’t mean he only missed your sparkling personality.

She looks rather unsettled, but plays it off as she must be getting sick. Then she exits through a side door I’ve never seen before. Is it a back entrance to the living quarters?

David and Owen exchange a serious look. “Time for Plan A,” Xanatos says. Really, you have your plans officially lettered? For most people, it’s just a concept, not an actual title.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - xanatos and owen start plan a

Owen is as expressive as a brick wall throughout the scene. Man, I love these guys!

And Now You Know

At the clock tower, Elisa is telling the gargoyles about her adventure. Goliath semi freaks out, blaming himself because he wasn’t there. After The Mirror adventure where they were able to express and grow their feelings for each other, Goliath is more willing to show his bond with Elisa.

Elisa says it’s impossible for him to protect her all the time, just as it’s impossible for her to protect them all the time.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - elisa and goliath

“Everyone’s vulnerable.” Foreshadowing!

How did the gargoyles not encounter the werebeast before? If today is Halloween, and this has been going on all month, then shouldn’t they have crossed paths? The Gen U Tech subjects get loose, and the gargs spot them in about 4 seconds. A werebeast runs rampant, eating the town out of house and home, and they don’t notice? I woulda thought Broadway would consider this Top Priority.

The Trio is more interested int the fact that it’s Halloween, where they can walk the streets freely. This too comes from their taste of community during The Mirror. Lex, however, gets worked up because it’s Fox.

Animal Magnetism

Back at the castle, Fox is in her room (which is bigger than my entire house), watching the moon through her open window. She’s in dread of something. As the moon rises, she looks at her hands. Oh, I’ve seen enough werewolf movies to guess what happens next.

Xanatos walks it. Yep, wasn’t expecting that. Neither was Fox. He announces that he wants to get the Eye of Odin engraved. He’s nothing if not tactful!

He’s going to have to wait. Fox begins to transform into the werefox Elisa met. It’s a fantastic transformation! Quick, impressive. Clenching the Eye as pink light streams between her fingers, she reaches, with the last of her humanity, toward David. Now fully werebeast, she rips off what shreds remain of the trench coat.

Xanatos is gaping, stunned speechless except for the obligatory, “Wha-?!” If this wasn’t a family show, he’d be saying something else. Seeing his fiance turn because of a gift he gave her must be heart wrenching.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - xanatos surprised

When you’re so shocked you need your own background. Well, it’s not every day your fiance turns into a werebeast before your eyes.

He was semi expecting this, though, so he recovers in record time. Whipping out a pistol, he shoots a dart into her shoulder. She roars but pulls it out and proceeds to throw him down on her bed. Whooooaaa now! Goin’ primal! There’s some wild energy in this bedroom. Fox is on top of him, holding him down.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - fox holds david down on bed

Even Xanatos might be out of his league here – and he knows it.

According to Greg: I’ll just quote the memo: “There’s some powerful primal energy swirling ’round that room. Lucky thing Owen is there, or I’m not sure Xanatos escapes with his dignity intact.”

Showing amazing control, he calmly calls Owen in. Owen bursts in and fires a dart into Fox’s back.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - owen shoots fox

Owen’s life is never dull.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - werefox and david on bed

Not exactly how he expected life with Fox to go. Pretty sure being in bed together didn’t mean this.

Meantime, David rips a curtain off the fourposter and tosses it over Fox. He tackles her legs, leaving an unfortunate Owen to grapple with her top half. She flings them both across the room. Hope you boys didn’t like having your ribs in one piece!

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - owen and david hold down werefox

I see who drew the short straw tonight.

Then she lopes off, tears the elevator open, bowls over Bruno and his Xanatos Enterprises Security Forces, and explodes out a window.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - fox takes on bruno security

Well, that didn’t go quite to plan.

In Xanatos’s office, Owen is at the widescreen, analyzing the data from the tracker he shot Fox with. It gives info on her metabolism, which is sky high. He says that if it stays at this rate, she’ll burn out before morning. “She’ll die.” Wow, this is a Disney show? Love it.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - owen looks at fox's metabilism tracker

Temp 108, Heart rate 220, BP 260/?. She’s going to fry her brain, kill her heart, and have a stroke at this rate.

Xanatos turns away from Owen, looking downcast and slightly worried. This is the first time I’ve seen this in David. He desperately tries to avoid showing any emotions for Fox, instead claiming he’d never have just given the Eye away if he knew its powers. Roughly translated, “Crap, it’s all my fault.” We already know how much he loves Fox, even if he won’t admit it. Nobody goes through all the trouble he did in Leader of the Pack to get a person out of jail a few months early if they don’t love said person.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - xanatos sad about fox

It’s a refreshing yet sobering to see someone who’s always in control and tough get taken down a few notches. Seeing real emotion other than satisfaction and amusement in him is welcome.

He’s gotta be thinking about what life would be like without Fox, and how it would be his doing. Not a pleasant mental tour.

Now it’s time for Plan B: Owen calls Elisa with an anonymous tip of where to find the werefox.

Plan B of A, B, C, and D

Xanatos gears up and flies out, using his exo-armor’s onboard GPS to track Fox’s beacon.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - xanatos hunts fox in armor

Good thing this guy is a huge fan of trackers!

He finds her at Felices Meats, Est 1934. She’s devouring a side of beef. I can totally sympathize with her. Some days you just want to eat a cow, rare.

Side note: Why doesn’t she just order in a bunch of food to her room? Nobody would notice.

David stalks in wearing full exo-armor and carrying one heck of a tranq gun. It’s the same type of gun Bruno’s squad had. It’s no surprise to him that she’s here. He predicted that her humming-bird-like metabolism would force her to eat almost constantly. (So…what’s my and the rest of America’s excuse?).

He sneaks through the forest of hanging meat, while Fox hunts him? Hides from him? Hard to tell.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - xanatos meets werefox


Fox bursts out from between the slabs of meat and chews a chunk out of the armor’s right shoulder, then throws him into a pole.

With his visuals fried, David removes his helmet. Fox is on him before he can stand. In an incredible show of trust, confidence, and resignation, he closes his eyes and turns his head as she roars and slobbers over him.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - fox holds david down

When you’re so hot werewolves won’t eat you.

Fox gets a good look at the purdy man before her. The werebeast’s white eyes turn blue, Fox’s color. Their relationship is real, and it is strong. With a screaming howl, she gallops off. How many of her actions is she aware of? Is she running away because she almost killed her lover? Looks that way.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - fox recognizes david

(when the animators remember, otherwise they’re green)

He looks determined and a bit pissed as he recovers.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - xanatos mad

I love that he’s more determined than ever to save her.

Fox lands outside after jumping out the window. She looks up – and catches Goliath’s foot in her face.

Disney Gargoyles - Eye of the Beholder - goliath attacks

All I can see in this is Elisa’s rear. Sorry. If I were her, I’d be pissed if he decided to kick a werewolf while carrying me.


I am loving this episode! It’s almost all Xanatos, Owen, and Fox. How novel is it to see David losing his control, losing his composure, and losing his girlfriend? The situation is forcing him to show his love for her. He’s risking his life and Owen’s life. But both men are more than willing to put their necks on the line for her. What a woman, and what men. I love seeing characters who seem to have it all together and who are the “strong ones” struggle to save their loved ones. The emotional force of that situation is gripping.

Now that the clan is involved, things are about to get even more interesting!

Tune in Friday to see how many plans Xanatos has to go through before he rescues his mate from herself.

Thoughts? Comment!

Related Articles:

Gargoyles: The Silver Falcon – Episode Review Continued

Gargoyles: The Silver Falcon – Episode Review

Gargoyles: The Mirror – Episode Review Continued

Gargoyles: The Mirror – Episode Review

Gargoyles: Lighthouse in the Sea of Time – Episode Review Continued

Gargoyles: Lighthouse in the Sea of Time – Episode Review

Gargoyles: Legion – Episode Review Continued

Gargoyles: Legion – Episode Review

Gargoyles: Metamorphosis – Episode Review Continued

Gargoyles: Metamorphosis – Episode Review

Lead researcher at Villainous Life Natures Research. Writer, reader, snarker. Lover of all things Geek and Dark. INTJ.
Read my reports at and learn how understanding villains can help you succeed in life.
Find my action-adventure post-apocalypse zombie thriller Wolves of the Apocalypse series at
I write fiction because the characters in my head have too much attitude to stay in my skull, I want to see the world through different eyes, and I want to live life through different souls.

Posted in Gargoyles, Post, Report Tagged with: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
2 comments on “Gargoyles: Eye of the Beholder – Episode Review
  1. GregXB says:

    The proposal was perfect for Xanatos. Absolutely in character.

    “I’ve heard some people say this is a lame proposal plan, one not worthy of Xanatos. ORLY? Do tell how a private, elegant, direct proposal with its reason based on logic and common interest is not Xanatosian? Xanatos isn’t going to mince words. He has intense respect for Fox; his actions stem from this attitude. In this proposal scene, he is 100% the charming, ambitious man Fox fell in love with.”

    Some people? More like one person. I know exactly who you’re talking about… and he has sour grapes because 2003 TMNT isn’t on the same pedestal as Gargoyles. 🙂

    BTW, I love your reviews. I should make a habit of commenting

    • LC Champlin says:

      You nailed it; that’s the person. I think there was one other person, and they were on Twitter. It’s because of said TMNT fan that I always have to get my digs in on how appropriate the proposal scene is. I actually liked some of their posts, but then I got pissed off and stopped reading when they accused Xanatos Enterprises of being involved in human trafficking.

      Thanks so much for reading! I’m thrilled you enjoy them. Hey, all comments are appreciated.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *